This area is for notices and items of interest to all car owners. Below you will find links to important governmental agencies as well as some current items. If you know of an item that you feel car collectors should know about, please submit it to the webmaster for consideration for inclusion on this site.
| Read our Fall 2025 Newsletter Read our Spring 2025 Newsletter Read our Spring 2026 Newsletter |
Association of California Car Clubs
Statement on the California Energy Commission Replacement Tire Efficiency Program
Adopted August 17, 2026
The Association of California Car Clubs opposes the Replacement Tire Efficiency Program adopted 5–0 by the California Energy Commission. Five appointed commissioners, not the voters, decided which replacement tires may be sold in this state. AB 844 (2003) directed the CEC to make replacement tires, on average, as efficient as original-equipment rubber. Twenty-three years later the Commission used that statute to cap rolling resistance on most passenger and light-truck tires made on or after January 1, 2029, and to tighten the cap again on January 1, 2033. Tires already on cars and tires built before those dates stay legal. Competition, winter, certain all-season winter-performance, large off-road, motorcycle, deep-tread, small-rim, and some other specialty tires were carved out after industry and enthusiast pressure. Everyday all-seasons and many performance street tires were not.
The staff case rests on a faulty reading of the data. Testers measured hundreds of different tires and found almost no statistical pattern linking “more efficient” with “worse in the rain” or “wears out faster” when all those tires were dumped into one chart. Staff told the Commission that therefore efficiency does not hurt grip or tread life. That leap is the error. A mixed chart of cheap all-seasons, touring tires, truck tires, and high-performance tires is not the same as asking what happens when one tire is forced to roll easier. Tire makers have said for years that if you change the rubber to save fuel, you often give up wet grip, miles, or both. Continental and the U.S. Tire Manufacturers Association put that on the record. Even the Commission’s own contractor found a clearer link between efficiency and wear when looking at economy and “fuel efficient” tires by themselves. The Commission treated a blurry group photo as proof that tradeoffs do not exist. That is how a unanimous vote was built on a method that cannot carry the conclusion.
Cost is the second failure. CEC published incremental figures of about $1.50 per tire in Phase 1 and $6.50 in Phase 2, paid back in months at $4.60 gasoline. Goodyear, Yokohama, the California Tire Dealers Association, Dunlop, and Falken said those numbers are laboratory deltas, not shelf prices after catalogs shrink. Discount Tire told the Commission that roughly 70 percent of what it sells in California would have failed the earlier Phase 2 draft. That is one retailer’s mix, not a census—and CEC never rebutted it. Fourteen legislators, including Assemblymember Lori Wilson, asked for a pause and a real market study. USTMA asked for a formal review of Phase 1 before Phase 2. The Commission locked the tighter 2033 number with no off-ramp. If cheaper tires disappear first, or if wear shortens life, drivers buy more often. More scrap and more tire-wear particles are not a rounding error in an “environmental” rule.
Enforcement is California-only and self-certified. Underinflation already wastes more energy than the rolling-resistance gap this program chases. The Commission regulated the hard variable and left the easy one alone.
The vote itself shows the accountability problem. KCRA’s Ashley Zavala has said she and her photographer were the only journalists in the hearing room. She learned of the vote from legislators and the tire industry, not from a CEC media alert. After her reporting drew national attention, the Commission’s spokesperson emailed her before 5 p.m. and urged her to “consider taking a different tone.” She published the email. She did not change the story. ACCC thanks her for that. A five-member board that can restrict a safety product sold to every California driver should not also be coaching the one reporter who showed up.
ACCC’s position is simple. We strongly oppose this rule. It will reduce choices that should be made by owners and drivers, and it may shrink the tires available for classic and specialty vehicles. Publish the numbers so buyers can choose. Do not ban the mid-price all-season that keeps a daily driver or a classic car on the road because a mixed chart was treated as physics. The Legislature should require a Phase 1 lookback, a cost study using actual retail prices, and a vote by elected members before Phase 2 takes effect.
Bill Adams
ACCC Director
Oakdale, CA
